Mark W. Bennett, U.S. District Court (Northern District of Iowa), and Ira P. Robbins, American University – Washington College of Law, are extraordinary thinkers, writers and researchers. Their new work, entitled Last Words: A Survey and Analysis of Federal Judges’ Views on Allocution in Sentencing, (March 10, 2014), is required, and I mean required, reading for any lawyer who represents a federal criminal defendant facing sentencing.
The last thing that takes place before a sentence is imposed in federal court is the defendant’s personal statement to the judge–allocution. After more than 20 years, and a 1,000 plus allocutions, I have a dirty little secret to admit.
Sometimes, when the allocution is raw with begging and bargaining and terror and fear, I will take my glasses off as I look directly into the defendant’s eyes. When I do, the defendant’s facial features becomes fuzzy and obscured and indistinct even though I appear to be focused on the face. I know that doing so is cowardly. But when I reject the plea for mercy, it helps to get me through the long nights that follow. After all, it’s all about me.