The evisceration of Dahlia Lithwick

Scott Greenfield

Scott Greenfield

If you want to read a great piece of critical legal writing, page through Scott Greenfield’s piece Horse-Trading Constitutional Rights. Scott incisively dissects a poorly reasoned article written by the very bright Dahlia Lithwick for Slate entitled The Courts’ Baffling New Math.

Dahlia Lithwick

Dahlia Lithwick

To be clear, I pimp Scott’s piece primarily because it is an example of excellent legal writing. Moreover, but less importantly, I agree with his point. Finally, Lithwick can be a tiresome scold. Taking her down several pegs is a good thing if you care about intellectual rigor and the national legal commentariat.

RGK

%d bloggers like this: